Grand Fishknights of Oceania (GAME OVER- Scum and Survival Third Parties WIN)

[Schazer]

Yeah sorry man, 's 'cause I tend to struggle to get any useful info without getting somewhat myopic. Hence I like to do things like compare D1 and D2 behaviours when, y'know. I'm actually trying.

Course, D2's a fair bit shorter albeit for not good reasons (luuuurkers) but El's sheeping onto my slot after Dini and Laset makes me hope he gets strapped to a bomb or some shit. Biometrics has been distracting me this evening but I won't be too much longer.

[Mirdini]

Course, D2's a fair bit shorter albeit for not good reasons (luuuurkers) but El's sheeping onto my slot after Dini and Laset makes me hope he gets strapped to a bomb or some shit.

Watts Schazer ENM claimed survivor who's also Dragon Fogel's role from either RCF1 or 2 (turns invincible if he gets enough votes, probably softlynch).

I'm sure a vig will take care of him soon enough though I'm surprised they didn't last night.

doop

[Laset]

I want enm vigged. I want enm vigged badly.

[Schazer]

Ok and here is my D2 chicken scratchings

show spoiler

hide spoiler

Sinjin->Crilly? #406

Eido's (nee no-post Scoffles') Namboto defence @410 is a thing, 'specially that "but can we trust the leaders" shtick, that is mine give it back and oh gods that last question Lynch: Eidolonic

Laset's defence of Sinjin #426 is still goofy and then if we keep entertaining my pet theory of Lasetscum #428 is "let's shoot into a barrel, I'll arbitrarily pick someone and that'd totally be good as random, right"

Potato Panic, Sinjin, seastorm were all people

Inoxfy get your arse out here right now
I want seastorm's words as well for post-N1 comparison reasons and then yes jumps straight on Namboto's claim

@Sotek's #436
"Of Seastorm, Eidolonic, and armoredSkunk, if you had to pick one to make unlynchable and one to kill, who would it be? and why?"

Unlynchable armouredSkunk for best of a nebulous, low-post-count bunch. Eidolonic's #410 makes me uneasy, issues with seastorm have not improved for all the posts I've read up to this point (or the lack thereof in D2). Probably just lurk-kill seastorm right now

Ok Doofaeus' reads at #453 are a mixed bag, partly annulled by lack of content by many slots. Weird to mention Watts of all the minimal-posters, and some other assessments are weird. Less comfortable about the ex-Paranoia.

Oh hey here I come

hmm starting to maybe see some people's case on ~ATH, #462 does give me the twitches

Crap crap crap why are we not lynching seastorm is there something I'm missing here

#474 was clearly a whale tail, MrVic's post was weeeeird

Namboto may as well try and save your arse with a full flavourclaim please

Also because I'm a replacement this goes to me:
Because Skunk and Feral have taken my original choices of Dini and Skunk, I will have to choose goddamn lessee

show spoiler

hide spoiler

--Best--
Mirdini
Skunk
Aci*
FeralFantom
Laset
Doofaeus
~ATH
Tea
Namboto
Mr. Vic
Potato Panic
Sinjin
Seastormjt
ENM
--Worst--

--Megaworst enough I cannot get a read, please post or request a replacement--
Inoxfy
Wateryhell
Watts
Kieros
Eidolonic

Ok, according to this my top three after taking out already-selected peeps I get Aci, FeralFantom, and Doofaeus - ~ATH if I'm not allowed Aci, which is testament to either my near-absolute mistrust, or a shallow-as-fuck pool due to everyone bar Namboto below ~ATH not posting enough (and ~ATH would've ranked a bit higher if not for vanishing D2). I would be happiest with shooting ENM in the face, Seastorm if I have a second bullet.

Namboto's claim is screwy but I cannot envision him being dumb enough to say a thing that isn't even a player was investigated - in that vein, I would not imagine him were he scum telling town more than was necessary to save his hide. Would still appreciate a flavour claim because you are still a tolerable lynch if we cannot run over seastormjt with a Marianas Trench-length train today.

[Schazer]

Oops I set my sights off Seastorm in my ramblings, y_not probably won't read spoiler votes but just in case have a Vote: Seastormjt again

[Namboto]

I'll copy paste my flavor if you want (I really have no idea why Strawberry Ice Cream came up as a result, hence the (?))

Astrid Anglert - Archivist

A bookworm in the order, little Astrid still doesn't seem fit in with the others. Many outside the order speculate to why this is so, ranging from the running theory of horrible body odor, to the much lesser idea that she has a disfigured hook hidden in her robe. As it can be, the truth is much stranger...

Back before Astrid joined the fishknights, she was a simple, but avid, reader. Often visiting used bookstores and libraries, she had long since passed the era of just being content with the normal selection. She started to look for the older, and more mystical series of books that littered the back of her usual haunts. Among these, were a few books that... did quite a bit more than impart the knowledge that was printed in ink. Dark knowledge, that Astrid would use to get an edge, one that she used only for the Grand Fishknights.

At night, you may examine the contents of your SECRET BLACK TOMES under the index of either Investigative Visits, Doctor Visits, or Kill Visits. Examining these will indicate who has been targeted by these varieties of actions over the course of the game including the current nightphase, but will not indicate who or in what matter these occur.

[Schazer]

Iiiii would not have considered copy-pasting a PM kosher in a game I ran, but Y_Not never technically posted any rules so fair's fair?

I honestly am not keen to lynch the dude with an easily-busted potential bluff today, not when seastorm and half a dozen lurkers are still things.

Like, if he's scum and trying to save his hide with a ballsy fakeclaim, the ice cream is stupid. Scum trying to save their skins by claiming their actual investigative role would not add seemingly-extraneous information that most of the town wouldn't have any clue about anyway. Town wouldn't have missed the extra point of information having never seen it, so scum would've gotten the edge in being informed.

I'm well aware this is pretty homework/homeowners logic I'm employing here, but more to the point why is seastorm allowed to hide from my royal arse-whooping I wanna give 'em today seriously

[feralFantom]

I support the Nam lynch (not voting cause hammers)
But I am all for getting other shit done today too and storm is a scumread for me so sure I will assist you Schazer
Vote: ssjt

[Namboto]

Iiiii would not have considered copy-pasting a PM kosher in a game I ran, but Y_Not never technically posted any rules so fair's fair?

I actually was also really unsure about it but I already gave some flavor earlier (creepy girl with a creepy book) so I wasn't quite sure what you wanted.

And feral, I'm saying it now, I don't trust you whatsoever, simply because you're leaving out a very important part of your reads: WHY

VOTE: fF

[mr_y_not]

My fault for not posting the rules, but normally this would be modkillable.

Fun fact, though: Scum have access to free fakeclaims.

[Namboto]

My fault for not posting the rules, but normally this would be modkillable.

Fun fact, though: Scum have access to free fakeclaims.

If I ever doubt again, I'll be sure to ask.

[feralFantom]

slap Namboto in the face with a fish

I'm going to sleep now, posting when I wake up

[mr_y_not]

Namboto has been successfully slapped right in the cheek with a fish.

[~ATH]

Real nice of you to activate an event and run off to bed without answers.

At this point, still happy with a Namboto lynch, that claim is just a tad too iffy to believe. Possible fake claim, possible scum role, etc.

Also seems to be relying on claims a bit overmuch.

Also: Of course I also want seastorm dead, she never stopped looking scummy from yesterday. That's best for tomorrow, however, as this thing on Namboto doesn't show signs of stopping.

[Sinjin]

No one is going to call me out. Anyone?

[Mirdini]

I honestly am not keen to lynch the dude with an easily-busted potential bluff today, not when seastorm and half a dozen lurkers are still things.

Like, if he's scum and trying to save his hide with a ballsy fakeclaim, the ice cream is stupid. Scum trying to save their skins by claiming their actual investigative role would not add seemingly-extraneous information that most of the town wouldn't have any clue about anyway. Town wouldn't have missed the extra point of information having never seen it, so scum would've gotten the edge in being informed.

I'm well aware this is pretty homework/homeowners logic I'm employing here, but more to the point why is seastorm allowed to hide from my royal arse-whooping I wanna give 'em today seriously

I agree pretty much entirely here. Unvote.

Going to go look at seastorm and if I've even commented on her

oh right that was a thing that was a thing

which is why I wasn't and probably still don't really want to go after seastorm sorry Schaz :S. Could be wrong there and she's actually scum but the vibes I was/am getting aren't that.

Feralfantom's jump there is very much a thing though! Cool beans.

Jacquerel (8 ) (50,000 Unstoppable Watts!, Slayer0, Acionyx, Mirdini, Laset, PotatoPanic, [A Killer Cuppa Tea], El Ninja Monkey, seastormjt, [GenetiXientist], Crilly)

I get why you want the Potato Panic slot dead Sotek, it's just reading her posts I really want to think she's town ;-;

but yeah on a second glance she's been talking about Jacquerel/Namboto/seastorm/Sinjin and pretty much no-one else throughout the entire game if you check her posts which is not a very townish thing, and that wagon is not pretty to boot. Especially if the seastorm thing is a thing like I think it is.

Vote: Potato Panic

[Mirdini]

Wow I haven't felt this scum on ~ATH in a while. Good to have you back mate.

Fish-slap was proooobably not an event and just a silly flavor thing a la Acio 'whack darcy with my cane' in Quarantine.

Sinjin:

The fact he's not actually being scummy at all, the fact that his wagon was made of nothing but scummy mcscumsters, the fact he looks like a townie who isn't trying instead of a scum who isn't trying?

like, there is nothing actually bad about sinjin except for lack of effort.

sure, I'll call you out for POST MORE CONTENT GODDAMMIT but yeah

[Mirdini]

wait schazer you replaced slayer0 but I want you to be town ahhhhhh

why'd you have to replace slayer0 that slot was baaaaaad news which is why we wanted to lynch it at the start of the day ;-;

I mean your posts since replacement have been absolutely excellent but now I have to just take everything you say with a CAUTION: SCUMMY SLOT DAY ONE sticker plastered over it (you're certainly not gunning for a lynch like Slayer0 would've been but yeah)

For the general populace: Still don't want to lynch Namboto though. Still voting Potato Panic and don't want to vote or lynch seastorm.

[A Killer Cuppa Tea]

Thoughts since my last post:

Schaz turns around my view of Slayer-slot completely. Taken with a grain of salt because although Slayer could have been scummy town, Schaz plays a wicked-sick scum game. A question though (and perhaps a little self-centered), why is there no mention of my in your walls at all, anywhere, Schaz? Also when you were posting your three towniest reads, you had me in the "shallow-as-fuck pool [of] everyone bar Namboto below ~ATH [who are] not posting enough", but at the time i had more posts than Namboto. What gives?

Namboto is...eh. A thing, i guess. One thing that i didnt want to bring to attention earlier is this:

Last night GX, Sinjin, Tea, MV, Strawberry Ice Cream (?), and Eido were checked.

Thats 5(6?) different checks. How many info roles do we have even...? (Rhetorical question, but that number looks hugely inflated to me).


I'm sorta-kinda ok with sinjin pressure if absolutely no alternatives, but i'm still sticking with PP as my go-to lynch atm.

PreviewEdit: Oh yea, ssjt... remind me to reread ssjt's posts some time later on today or tomorrow.

[feralFantom]

Alright, the slap thing is as far as I know just a slap thing and has no actual effect on anything

As for reasons, storm has been scummy all game from my perception. Lots of weird stuff and overdefending, and also things like oops I guess I had better do this so that im following my own advice. Seems like if your actions aren't akin to your opinions on other people, its likely made up. I was and am still feeling good about a nam lynch, but want to explore other avenues as well today

[armoredSkunk]

I actually didn't feel too bad about slayer's posts after a reread so I'm cool with Schazer.

But hey! Guess who else I am feeling better about after a reread? (hint:ssjt)

In actuality I think ~ATH was being overly aggressive from the get-go and seastorm's "chainsaw defense" wasn't so much that. It looks more like a casual remark taken too seriously. That said, I don't necessarily think she's town because of the way she has played since but this was still a thing.

I am also quasi-convinced that namboto is town now. unvote :/

So my overall thoughts right now are vote seastormjt because even though I'm not fully convinced, she is certainly laying low right now.

BUT if we end up lynching her and she is town I want ~ATH deaddeaddead because he was a bit wishy-washy with Jacg yesterday and he's been all over seastorm/sinjin since that incident which was practically from RVS.

(Or if anyone feels like a Watts!lynch could be a thing that happens today I'd be all over that.)

[Solaris]

Making Mod Events for Shits and Giggles Edition

========== Lynch
====== Softlynch

==Potato Panic (2) - A Killer Cuppa Tea, Mirdni
=====Namboto (6) - Sotek, 50,000 Watts, Potato Panic, Doofaeus, ~ATH, Mister Visceral
=ENM (1) - ENM
===seastormjt (3) - Schazer, FeralFantom, armoredSkunk
=FeralFantom (1) Namobto

With 19 alive, it takes 10 to lynch, 6 to softlynch. The day's deadline will be 12:00 am EST, May 7th.

[Schazer]

That's best for tomorrow, however, as this thing on Namboto doesn't show signs of stopping.

NOT IF I CAN HELP IT, BUSTER

Call it serious second-guessing, but doesn't a roleclaim that would entail all investigatives verifying it be the dumbest/uber-ballsiest scum claim? "Let's not bother turning a lynch train on a potentially-useful claimed role around" is the most bollocks. Especially when we've got six days to shift this.

Also Dini if Seastorm is not scum and Potato Panic is, and ~ATH is another, then who would the rest of the scum by by your book? Can we shoot all the lurkers in the face yet?

@Tea: my ranked reads clearly place you under "did some good stuff D1 but arguably made a better job of himself vanishing D2 compared to what he's said so far*" ~ATH but above "Arguably-decent D2 lynch du jour until a reasonable claim was raised" Namboto. I'd say you're now above ~ATH who's slipped below Namboto, but that's more because of what they're doing than what you're doing. My read of what you've done in this game so far was "mostly bay for Aci's blood when he was clearly doing his trademark overt misaggroing on Jacqs at the end of D1". If you've done something else to make me feel good about you, it didn't register on my re-reads.

Anyway seeing as Sinjin has clearly been active and following the thread but not contributive I want him up to soft lynch so he's got an incentive to words properly. Vote: Sinjin

[Mirdini]

Also Dini if Seastorm is not scum and Potato Panic is, and ~ATH is another, then who would the rest of the scum by by your book? Can we shoot all the lurkers in the face yet?

24 players means ~6 scum maaaaaybe 6 scum and a traitor. Out of the talky people I did also mention MV as a guy I sort of want dead. So PP/~ATH/MV and yeah I can see the other 3-4(?) scum being lurkers. Your slot ain't super-clear either but as aforementioned you're playing super-awesomely so I'm certainly not going to want you lynched anytime soon (can someone cop schazer that'd be p. cool).

[Sinjin]

Thing is despite the information I could gather I fear of being accused of parroting.

So I am taking a slightly different approach which means you need to check a certain something which I am quoting now.

So is the one who checked me a role/flavorcop? If so. I can understand why you are avoiding me. *Hinthint*

It's like I have to shove down my own miniclaim down your throats to get even the slightest bit of obvious information.