Grand Fishknights of Oceania (GAME OVER- Scum and Survival Third Parties WIN)

[Eidolonic]

Missing something... probably.

And not sure if I feel better or worse about Tea after that Infoxy vote. Though I do agree with Potato Panic needing poked. Or killed.

[Acionyx]

I'm gonna assume the tradeoff is that you're doc'd during that period?

Also, did Schaz just claim SK or am i missing something?

Person on the other end claimed it was but I think that's a bunch of crap

Things the role does:

-roleblocks you
-allows you to talk to the jailer
-vanishes you for the following day DURING WHICH YOU CANNOT TALK TO THE JAILER


The thing is a fucking glorified silencer and my firespitting tirade at the jailer aside they didn't go out of their way to try and chat things up with me

Given the handful of edgecase antitown roles and everything about this one I lean scum on whoever has it especially because they are targetting majortype players when anyone with a brain would realize how damaging that role is. It's like Airey in quarantine claiming to have "protected" tildeath when he was on course to slaughter one of his teammates.


PS I think it's YOU

PSS I know dini is jailed because of modslip

[Potato Panic]

Okay, so I'm back in action finally! : >
Sorry I wasn't here for daystart, if you weren't notified, I was gone Tuesday - Thursday because of AP History (which went horribly btw).
Anywhooooooooo
I agree Inoxfy could do with a good prodding because of the lurking in the darkness before appearing to ask for other peoples reads on what was going on accompanied by bandwagoning blatantly on MV with minimal reasoning (and faulty with proposed role-claim) ?
The only issue with this is that arguably, this could be too blatant to actually be something scum would do? Unless low effort/ kinda derping scum? Either way I'd like to see a response from Inox before I do some voting for him.
Additionally is ~ATH around? Cause Overly-Aggressive-Then-Nonexistent ATH is still a thing I would like to see less of really. Vote: ~ATH
Also would still be okay with Sinjin being deadeeeeeeeeeeed or a least held at cutlass point until words that aren't magic-bagging flavoury role weirdness come out his mouth.
YO SINJIN
WHAT'S YOUR DEAL?
(And how do you feel about peeps post-MV lynch?)

[Acionyx]

Hi let's play a game

Inoxfy is not the person I want to actually lynch today although he is someone I want shaken like a broken vending machine


Can anyone guess who I really want to die

[A Killer Cuppa Tea]

Person on the other end claimed it was but I think that's a bunch of crap

Things the role does:

-roleblocks you
-allows you to talk to the jailer
-vanishes you for the following day DURING WHICH YOU CANNOT TALK TO THE JAILER

Welp.

That doesnt sound like a very helpful role.

I guess the best way to use it would prolly be to use it as a roleblocking, and fuck the sideeffects.

any ideas on who the RB is?

[Eidolonic]

You.

Directed at Tea, of course. Who is also the answer to Acio's question.

[feralFantom]

that post seems really "I already know the answers to these questions-y
especially asking who he thinks is RB

coupled with what could be you trying to make your role look townier, when at least the way it is being used is very anti-town

Vote: Tea

[Schazer]

Uuuuugh.

Tea's undue fascination with the role is fully in line with someone who's trying their damnedest to keep their pants on. Considering the way he's been playing it I can't really justify it as protown.

Vote: Tea while I go have a look and see what that might mean in terms of other people scumming it up with him

[Eidolonic]

PS I think it's YOU

any ideas on who the RB is?

Not sure if Tea is derping or what, but, uhhh.

People I don't like, that I have no clue on connections. Will need to re-read to look at interactions:

Tea, Infoxy, Potato Panic, ATH, Kieros.

I, uh... I'm cool with making Infoxy show up and contribute? Same with Kieros?

[Doofaeus]

Ahhhhh my dearest tea, looks like finally my suspicions were grounded. Your fascination over Acio and your curiosity over the role seem forced. you were also very much against the acio's still alive theory. Pretty much all of your statements indicate you know more about what's going on and are just trying to say the exact opposite of your knowledge.

So what's up buddy

[A Killer Cuppa Tea]

hahahaha

you all vastly overestimate me

i sincerely hope you're not going to lynch me over suspecting me of being a role that A) Isn't mine, B) We're not even sure exists (we're depending on acio's word here) C) comes from someone who i tunelled hard during D1 and D) Tunelled me hard in return (its a bit of a coincidence that he comes back with TEA IS SCUM YO), E) If exists we dont even know if its a scum-role or a badly-played-role, and F) If exists what proof is there that its even me?

Further, i'm asking these questions to acio, not anyone else who is answering them. Why? Cos i'm still not convinced he's town. Sure, he aint my scummiest read, but damned if im gonna let him run the town scot free. Look back over his posts and forget its acio. Besides his leading-town meta, there's not a lot to say he's scum. And if the role is what he says it is, why the hell would scum not either vanish him two nights in a row (unless they cant) or kill him when he returns from his vanishing or something. The fact that he didnt die N1 makes me more suspicious of him rather than less.

As for "you were also very much against the acio's still alive theory", acio dies N1. It happens. A lot. The fact that many people jumped to the conclusion that just because his role wasnt flipped, he wasnt dead really struck me as odd. Especially if he is a scum false martyr or something wacky like that (or, i suppose, if this supposed jailer of his is scum), and certain people knew he'd be back. The fact that he is back should throw suspicion not only on him, but on the people who took it for granted that he wasnt dead.

[A Killer Cuppa Tea]

Bah, who'm i kidding

yea, im the jailer, its me

i jailed/blocked acio n1 cos i thought he was a vig/SK trying to kill me. At this point, im pretty damned sure he's town, even if only because he's so accurate about who's being jailed and whos doing it. I was trying to continue with the "acioscum" thing to hopefully draw a kill away from him, but eh, at this point he's townietown.

i jailed dini last night cos i had no idea what to do, and he gave me a good long earful on how i should have been using the role. I understand that ive been using the role incredibly wrongly, and shoulda treated it as a roleblocker rather than a masoner. He also told me to trueclaim, but when i saw the anger directed at the role i thought "fuck that, i'll just get lynched", and decided to carry on with the whole charade. But then i realised that lying of this sort has no benefit to town. So i trueclaim.

And prolly get lynched for my afforts
This has not been my best play ever ._.,

[Sinjin]

YO SINJIN
WHAT'S YOUR DEAL?

My deal? I am a disguiser that was posing as a Jester night one.

[Solaris]

Clam-Clam Edition

========= Lynch
===== Softlynch

===InoxFy (3)-ACIONYX, Doofaeus, Eidolonic
=El Ninja Monkey (1)-El Ninja Monkey
=~ATH (1)-Potato Panic
==A Killer Cuppa Tea (2)-Feral Fantom, Schazer


With 17 alive, it takes 9 to lynch, 5 to softlynch. The day's deadline will be May 23rd.

A Killer Cuppa Tea was slapped by a giant fucking fish like a page or two ago

[~ATH]

show spoiler

hide spoiler

Replacing out, sorry. Mafias just aren't my thing anymore. You will not be seeing this guy again, I promise. I've already caused too much trouble by signing up for games that I'm not going to play.

[Kíeros]

Great. Apparently, this started up and didn't change over. Just dandy.

Can anyone guess who I really want to die

Well, given this, I'd like to guess me.

I, uh... I'm cool with making Infoxy show up and contribute? Same with Kieros?

I'm fine with making me show up and contribute too!

Also sotek if you could tell me what you think of eido, skunk, and fantom it would be much appreciated
Same question to everyone really

Eido: He's new, but he's been extremely helpful. I though Scoffles was helpful and towny, and the same continues onto him.
Skunk: Somewhat like Eido; he feels townish to me. Not as much as Eido had felt when I went back and looked at stuff, but still I'd rather lynch a few other people before him.
Fantom: He's been weird, yes. I don't like the feeling I get from him, but not so much as in I want to lynch him right now. That's for another "friend" in this game.

My deal? I am a disguiser that was posing as a Jester night one.

Is it just me, or are disguisers usually not town... Sinjin, what does that entail?

[Acionyx]

Wow

WOW

I didn't really care about you and for the most part you slipped my mind but woooooooooow


For a start: you do know that scofflaw never posted during the actual game right? He was around for join shenanigans but he literally had zero involvment in the game proper

[Eidolonic]

Yeah, I uh. What.

If that's an attempt to make me want you less dead, it sort of... didn't work. At all. For the reason Acio said. I replaced in to a 100% null and inactive slot.

Kieros/Fantom scumbuddies? The 'I don't want to lynch them right now' thing is, uh. Hm.

[Kíeros]

Aarg; I knew I'd make some sort of stupid mistake. I only was reading for that near the middle of D2, as that was when all of them had replaced in. Okay, I goofed. I'll admit that.
On the other hand, the reason I don't want Fantom lynched now is just how bad Sinjin was in that post that I had quoted, along with numerous other times throughout. Fantom is high on my list of scum, but I'm not going to lynch number two-ish this early in the day while I can still start something on number one. If we get near the end, and Fantom's close to Soft, then I'd gladly vote for him; it's just Sinjin seems horrible today.

[Sinjin]

I always seem horrible though.

[Solaris]

REPLACEMENT HUNT 2012
WHAT BRAVE SOULS SHALL SAVE US FROM THE TWO EMPTY SLOTS OF
~ATH
INOXFY
PROBABLY MORE BECAUSE LURKS

[Acionyx]

Urgh patience is not a thing I have

Oi people Dini is stuck in stupid land probably yelling at you all as much as I was for moving so slow so fuck it here is everything I have:


Tea is not my ideal lynch choice today. There's a reasonable chance he's scum and if everything I'm assuming is correct he is extremely likely to be scum


The assumptions though come from SEASTORM. I have her as not likely aligned with: doofaeus, tildeathslot, potato panic and kind of obviously Schazer0slot. Seastorm comes up scum then all FOUR of those become pretty likely to be town. I honestly should have just stabbed her last night but Watts was a superlurky scumcandidate and I didn't feel like fighting a chorus of "BUT HE HASN'T DONE ANYTHING!!!"s

I'd have just started the day going after seastorm but I legit don't think there's anything to be had to change my mind about her except a potential roleclaim and from everything flipped so far I don't think there's a saving grace left TO claim.


OTHER THINGS

Eido has felt decentish to me today but he spent most of the night sitting on my list of possibilities. I think wrt Kieros he could be a likely suspect since kieros is really really likely to be scum what with his limited appearances and that blatant bit of bullshitting on reads up above.


The person I most want lynched today is seastorm since there's a good chance she's scum and she's at the center of an alignment tangle that's massively informative to me. I can live with any of the others but I think atm they're better targets for people who can do stabby things at night.


Lynch: Seastorm

[Eidolonic]

InoxFy replacing out is bluh, but clearly not going to be able to get anything useful out of that vote today.

Uh. Seastorm didn't jump out at me the first time through for some reason. But that may have been because I disliked Potato Panic more, and they aren't co-aligned? Hm. I'd be okay with seeing Seastorm flip, I guess? It'd make me feel better about Potato Panic if Seastorm does flip scum, and lets us PoE scum down pretty significantly, as Acio mentions... yeah, okay.

Lynch: Seastorm

[Kíeros]

I think wrt Kieros he could be a likely suspect since kieros is really really likely to be scum what with his limited appearances and that blatant bit of bullshitting on reads up above.

In order, I've been busy, and when I saw that the day had started well earlier, I immediately tried to get a post up as fast as possible. I'm sorry; can we get over that?

On ssjt, I'm fine with lynching him as well, but he's still seemingly inferior to Sinjin in my opinion, so I'll hold off on Mister Strawberry Ice Cream until nearer to the end, 'kay?

[Laset]

INCOMING MEGAWALL POST: (and no I'm not spoilering it because screw that.)

Seastorm selfvoted in RVSphase, post #97.

Sinjin you are my scummiest townread ever, goddamn why.

Megarock is looking ultrascummy in my RVS-phase reread, huh.

gwah, seastorm is looking v. scummy in 137...

... I'm kind of seeing seastorm bussing megarock in the early stuff. that's what it looks like to me. Hmm.

... why did we think Slayer0 was scummy, again. His posts don't read scummy anymore, wtf. (And then Schazerplacement.)

Tea's defense of Jacq as the wagon got going, hmm. That's ... not a good defense? Knowing Jacq is town, it's kind of the defense I'd expect a scum to make in order to look better later. Hrm.
... then he later votes Jacq and ... goddamnit tea stop being unreadable.
you want to be readable!!

Okay. I want Potato Panic and Seastorm dead as of end of D1.

Eidolonic #410: What the hell role were you thinking he was?

#435: Kieros shows up with a dubious post, voting Sinjin. Hi Kieros.

Ath ... feels mysteriously town, hrm.

Kieros/Seastorm/MegaVisceral/Potato Panic are all people I want dead, goddamn.

#471: wait, fF said Potato Panic is a null read that's basically a townread??? waaaat.

day two is ... very hmm. Not a lot of "good" stuff in there

Potato Panic's big readwall in #571 is ... not terrible, not great. and then she goes and votes Sinjin /o\

Hi again Kieros, #628. Voting seastorm makes you look better but ... still...

I see my D2 aS confusion and I don't know why. aS is townside of null. Maybe it's just because very null?


... right as I reread my D2 vote for MV I start to go "wait, this is looking like a wagon on a townie."
Too bad I didn't see that before. :V and he was starting to look antialigned to seastorm and PP...


uh. Who did Airey replace? I seem to have missed the replacementnotice and it's not in the OP

Lesse. Inoxslot is shady but replacement is replacement.

Eido asked me who I'd shoot tonight if I could, other than ENM. Uhhh, I'm gonna say Kieros right now. That popping in for a dubious post once/day is a Thing, and it's a Thing that means wagons are less likely to be interesting.
... I have no idea what Eido's reasons are here!

Acio: On the reread, skunk is townishnull, watts is almost ok in the two posts he made, tea is tea. Kieros I want dead, InoxFy I probably want dead but depends on replacement. Seastorm I want dead. Potato Panic I want extra dead after how D2 ended, btw.

Eido I dunno, townish null? Townier than skunk, not as towny as some. fantom ... don't have much. slightly scummy null?

oh god #749. TEA @_@

Acio: My guess as to who you want dead is Seastorm. Or Kieros. (PPE: Hey look! Seastorm!)

#766: HI KIEROS HI. PLEASE DEAD.

Anyway. vote: Seastorm although I really feel like there's some bussing involved around seastorm? Not ... /certain/ but the way Potato Panic survived D2 really looks like A Thing to me, and seastorm was part of that. In fact, Haemat and Seastorm were the two votes on MV that kind of lead the switchover. If PP is scum I'd be looking /really/ hard at those two?