Katia: You can't let that bitch get away with that! You're Katia Fucking Managan!
Burst in there, rip off that amulet, and demand your purr-operty back!
If she holds up some paper that claims you willingly gave her your stuff, use those claws and turn it into kitty litter!
No is not the time to lay down in submission like some house cat!
Go in there, claws raised! NOW is the time for a catfight for your honor!
Also- check the time by looking at the moon... I think that your Eye of Fear might be just about ready...
I think that it might be enough to purr-suade her.