My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic, Thread Four: TALKING IS NOW BANNED

[kd7sov]

Let's see if I can't decipher that...

Nope. Not a clue. I thought I might have, but it failed.

Incidentally, why "the two music ponies"? We've seen, if I recall correctly, nine. Well, nine fan-named, plus Andrea Libman's characters. Plus Lyra, who's got a musical cutie mark but hasn't been seen singing (outside of crowd songs) or with any physical instrument.

[*Sigh*]

Literally the only ones that I can think of off the top of my head are Scratch, Lyra, Octavia, and Octavia's bandmates, who I can't really remember the names of.

Oooh! Wait! There's that one guy that was kind of like a 63'd version of Scratch, and I believe Blues is a saxophone player?

[Triangle Man]

Why the hell am I Derpy?

And I guess my prelim-favorite-characters list would include.

1) Twilight Sparkle
2) Pinkie Pie
3) Fluttershy
4) Scootaloo
5) Doctor Whooves

If we're talking about the top five 'best ponies', then I have to say my list is...

1) Mr.Ed
2) Mr.Ed
3) Mr.Ed
4) Mr.Ed
5) Unicorn Zodiarts

...Hehehe...

[kd7sov]

Literally the only ones that I can think of off the top of my head are Scratch, Lyra, Octavia, and Octavia's bandmates, who I can't really remember the names of.

Oooh! Wait! There's that one guy that was kind of like a 63'd version of Scratch, and I believe Blues is a saxophone player?

Oh, right, Blues. I'd forgotten him. I was thinking Scratch, Octavia, the other three Gala players, and the four Nightmare Night players.

Anyway, yeah, there's a bunch. More than two, certainly.

[AProcrastinatingWriter]

I am not going to give out my list of favorite ponies.

Because out of all the anonymous people who read this topic and don't post I am moderately certain that at least one of them is stalking me.

And I like to imagine their reaction when they realize they will never know who my favorite ponies are.

I am imagining it involves heavy weeping.

[*Sigh*]

Literally the only ones that I can think of off the top of my head are Scratch, Lyra, Octavia, and Octavia's bandmates, who I can't really remember the names of.

Oooh! Wait! There's that one guy that was kind of like a 63'd version of Scratch, and I believe Blues is a saxophone player?

Oh, right, Blues. I'd forgotten him. I was thinking Scratch, Octavia, the other three Gala players, and the four Nightmare Night players.

Anyway, yeah, there's a bunch. More than two, certainly.

I refuse to believe that the Nightmare Night players did not include Octavia in a really good outfit.

[frostedWarlock]

Oooh! Wait! There's that one guy that was kind of like a 63'd version of Scratch

DJ W1SH? The guy with a shooting star cutie mark?

[*Sigh*]

Yes, exactly him. To be honest I don't know if the fandom has decided on whether or not he's Vinyl's brother or just some other dude that does DJ work.

[Triangle Man]

I saw a fancomic that basically shipped those two characters together. It was mildly amusing.

[*Sigh*]

Thus why I said that the fandom was undecided.

[orderboundChaotic]

I refuse to believe that the Nightmare Night players did not include Octavia in a really good outfit.

I thought that at first too, but then she showed up with her doppelganger in Sweet and Elite.
Compare:

show spoiler

hide spoiler

show spoiler

hide spoiler

[frostedWarlock]

Yes, exactly him. To be honest I don't know if the fandom has decided on whether or not he's Vinyl's brother or just some other dude that does DJ work.

From what I've seen, some people like to have Scratch be sisters with Allie Way. I haven't really seen much of DJ W1SH.

[*Sigh*]

I refuse to believe that the Nightmare Night players did not include Octavia in a really good outfit.

I thought that at first too, but then she showed up with her doppelganger in Sweet and Elite.
Compare:

show spoiler

hide spoiler

show spoiler

hide spoiler

God dangit you and your logic win this round, but I'll be back!

[kd7sov]

Hang on, you're referring to the violin-mare, right? The one who's got a different cutie mark (and mane color) than the one at Nightmare Night?

[orderboundChaotic]

Hang on, you're referring to the violin-mare, right? The one who's got a different cutie mark (and mane color) than the one at Nightmare Night?

Upon closer inspection, I'd saw that you're right. They're not the same pony, but it's still renders the costumed Octavia hypothesis as questionable. I don't know what to think anymore.

[Namboto]

Hang on, you're referring to the violin-mare, right? The one who's got a different cutie mark (and mane color) than the one at Nightmare Night?

Upon closer inspection, I'd saw that you're right. They're not the same pony, but it's still renders the costumed Octavia hypothesis as questionable. I don't know what to think anymore.

The mane's style is different too, the violinist in the second pic's hair is more fluffy

on the other hand, the violinist in NMN has octavia's hair and cutie mark


which probably just means that they recolored Octavia's model :|

[MESIAS_ROCKET]

If we're talking about the top five 'best ponies', then I have to say my list is...

1) Mr.Ed
2) Mr.Ed
3) Mr.Ed
4) Mr.Ed
5) Unicorn Zodiarts

...Hehehe...

I approve of this list.

[williamcll]

Hang on, you're referring to the violin-mare, right? The one who's got a different cutie mark (and mane color) than the one at Nightmare Night?

Upon closer inspection, I'd saw that you're right. They're not the same pony, but it's still renders the costumed Octavia hypothesis as questionable. I don't know what to think anymore.

The mane's style is different too, the violinist in the second pic's hair is more fluffy

on the other hand, the violinist in NMN has octavia's hair and cutie mark


which probably just means that they recolored Octavia's model :|

And the fans will make fan theories that they are relatives

EDIT:

I got through a chapter or two, but it just didn't stick with me, so I stopped reading. I have a friend who is a huge homestuck fan, so she's the one who got me to try it out <:

Guys

Help me get this amazing artist to read the whole HS series.

[AProcrastinatingWriter]

I got through a chapter or two, but it just didn't stick with me, so I stopped reading. I have a friend who is a huge homestuck fan, so she's the one who got me to try it out <:

Guys

Help me get this amazing artist to read the whole HS series.

Why? They've already tried it out and discovered they didn't like it. It's okay for them not to.

[Gradiant]

The only thing bad about this is associating Pinkie Pie with Equius. Just... NO

[*Sigh*]

No no no! That's perfect! Her coat looks a lot like troll's royal blood, and her antics would have Equius scrambling constantly. Hilarious!

[kholhaus]

Why does Derpy spell me to a T?

WHY?

WHY INTERNET?

e: Also Luna is Magnets.

[Coasterman29]

PFFFT AHAHAHA CANCER AND KARKAT

But I'm a Cancer, so yeah, somewhat close.

1. Vinyl Scratch
2. Pinkie Pie
3. Fluttershy (all the vocal dubs...)
4. Scootaloo
5. Lyra

[Inconspicularity]

Welp.

[*Sigh*]

God dangit! I was really hoping that he would like it for my friend's sake, as he is a big fan of Minecraft, and also a brony.